| Zobacz poprzedni temat :: Zobacz następny temat |
| Autor |
Wiadomość |
zagram_org
Dołączył: 04 Lut 2013
Posty: 33
|
 Wysłany: Czw Gru 14, 2017 9:57 am Temat postu: |
 |
|
| Volunteer napisał: | | zagram_org napisał: | | The fact that these are territory rules follows from this sentence |
| Volunteer napisał: | | under the game for the territory we understand different things |
And this is so. Before the filling of the whole field and, accordingly, with the creation of traps in the Soviet Union and in Russia they played until the middle of the 2000s. Many amateurs are playing now. But nobody calls it a game for the territory.
|
Well the names are not important 
If the players do not play until the board is full, but rather agree to finish when there is nothing to catch, then they effectively play with the 'stop buton' rule. And this is not a territory game. From what we see on Kropkoliga, it's difficult to say for sure what was the case. The rules allowed territory play. On the pictures we do not see it. But there are only few pictures...
| Volunteer napisał: |
| zagram_org napisał: | | Counting territory, like done on szkrab or zagram, is just for convenience |
But what you call simple convenience, from our point of view, is precisely the main sign of the game for the territory.
|
The main sign of the game for the territory is that we really play until the board is full -- well, for convenience we do not, but we count points just as we did play until the end.
| Volunteer napisał: |
| zagram_org napisał: | | It always simulates the result that would occur when playing until the board is full |
Not always. If you finish the game ahead of time, when there is a lot of empty space on the field (by the rules players can do it anytime), you fix the result only for the part of the field that is currently full. This does not mean that if the game was continued, the result would remain the same, because the final score will depend on how players place the dots on still free areas of the field. Counting the points, the system can not know this.
|
Of course. That's why the players have to agree that they count points, and typically they do it when there's really nothing to do.
http://eidokropki.reaktywni.pl/index.phtml?lang=en#url:zagram331597:0,441
http://eidokropki.reaktywni.pl/index.phtml?lang=en#url:zagram331173:0,571
| Volunteer napisał: |
| zagram_org napisał: | | It might be that the guys in Kropkoliga did not realise fully the consequences of their own rules, but someday they would see that if you have to play until the end, it's good to have some territory |
That's when it happens, then I'll say that the guys are playing for the territory. For the time being, I see the same "Soviet classics" in the photos of their games, which I write about in the article. If something looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then this duck is. And it does not matter that it really is a dog, but does not know about it
|
It might be, but we do not know.
Even if so, still, at some point they would realise that and then they would either follow their own rules with all their consequences (i.e., territory play), or they would adopt some kind of 'stop button'.
| Volunteer napisał: |
| zagram_org napisał: | | The Russian rules have 'stop' possibility, and this disables territory play |
Only in your understanding. For decades we played without a landing rule ("stop"), some are still playing, but nobody calls it a game for the territory, as I said above.
|
You are writing about something else, that no stop does not imply territory play 
But again, by the duck principle, if you formally play without "stop" but agree to stop when there's nothing to catch you effectively play with the stop rule. |
|
| Powrót do góry |
|
 |
senny_mojrzesz
Dołączył: 04 Lis 2005
Posty: 1566
Skąd: Legionowo,Londyn
|
| Wysłany: Czw Gru 14, 2017 1:01 pm Temat postu: |
|
|
For territory and without territory this was just interpretation and new names which started on zagram.org.
Nothing change in the rules.
Shortcut counting we just started using in szkrab
But we change nothing really in the game.
About kropkoliga screens. We don't know the rule which can make a big differend about closing dots.
This screen shows you nothing and you calling that "clear proof".
And this "conversation started" because you wrote something like this.
And we was just tried to explain you how it was in history.
From this screen in the link
https://www.dropbox.com/s/ei1kiji6bgi21ms/Screenshot_20171213-220034.png?dl=0
How you possibly can know which rules about closing dots was used
We don't know yet which rules about closing dots was first in Poland
And we don't know yet when first game was played.
And possible we will never know, but who knows |
|
| Powrót do góry |
|
|
Volunteer
Dołączył: 16 Lis 2017
Posty: 65
Skąd: Russia
|
| Wysłany: Czw Gru 14, 2017 3:00 pm Temat postu: |
|
|
| senny_mojrzesz napisał: | | This screen shows you nothing and you calling that "clear proof". And this "conversation started" because you wrote something like this |
I do not know what is the reason, perhaps in a double translation from English, but now you are just fighting with windmills.
"Soviet classics" is: the game until the free points of the field run out or until the players themselves decide that the result is obvious, an arbitrary encirclement trajectory, the absence of a landing rule ("stop"), the determination of the result by counting the surrounded dots only.
The rules of "Kropkoliga": "Gra kończy się z chwilą zapełnienia całej kartki, lub do momentu gdy jeden z graczy się podda, albo obaj się zgodzą skończyć grę i podliczyć punkty... Punkty otrzymuje się za każdą otoczoną kropkę przeciwnika, oraz traci za otoczone własne kropki".
Now show me the difference and explain what you did not like. The word "Soviet"? |
|
| Powrót do góry |
|
|
Volunteer
Dołączył: 16 Lis 2017
Posty: 65
Skąd: Russia
|
| Wysłany: Czw Gru 14, 2017 4:00 pm Temat postu: |
|
|
| zagram_org napisał: | | Well the names are not important |
The names do not matter, yes. But in this case it's not the name but the difference in approaches.
If you read the first part of the "History", which describes the origin of dots from Go, you can understand what is the difference.
A real game for the territory is Go. The most fully developed standard. The capture of the stones there plays a supporting role, the players receive most of the points for control of the territory. Anyone who has established such control can skip moves, so the game before filling the field and creating traps does not make sense. Dots appeared as a variation of Go and evolved as its antipode. The ultimate result of this evolution at the moment are the Russian rules, under which the territory does not make sense at all. During the development of the game several attempts have been made in one form or another to place the result of the game in dependence on the encircled territory. They were in the USSR, and in the post-Soviet countries, and in the Czech Republic, and in Poland. Good or bad is another matter. In my opinion, it's not good, because in any case it will be a surrogate for Go. Dots only makes sense as an antipode to Go, otherwise they turn into a parody of Go.
You are trying to find signs of game for territory where they are, from our point of view, not. The game before the filling of the field and the creation of traps is not a game for territory, it is a specific method of playing for capturing dots. The game for the territory appears only where the surrounded area itself gives points, regardless of the surrounding game chips (stones, dots - it does not matter). And in this sense, shortcut a la Szkrab is a step towards game for territory, because it allows under certain conditions to get points for surrounded empty spaces.
In the course of the discussion, I repeated many times the same thing: only scoring. If the number of points depends on the surrounding area (no matter how exactly it is counted), then this game is for territory. If the number of points depends only on the surrounded dots, then this is a game without territory. This is our position, with which you are not obligated to agree. As well as we are with yours. |
|
| Powrót do góry |
|
|
zagram_org
Dołączył: 04 Lut 2013
Posty: 33
|
| Wysłany: Czw Gru 14, 2017 11:59 pm Temat postu: |
|
|
| Volunteer napisał: | | "Soviet classics" is: the game until the free points of the field run out or until the players themselves decide that the result is obvious, an arbitrary encirclement trajectory, the absence of a landing rule ("stop"), the determination of the result by counting the surrounded dots only. |
Well I didn't know that, and in that case, there is no major difference between Soviet classics and Kropkoliga.
| Volunteer napisał: | You are trying to find signs of game for territory where they are, from our point of view, not. The game before the filling of the field and the creation of traps is not a game for territory, it is a specific method of playing for capturing dots. The game for the territory appears only where the surrounded area itself gives points, regardless of the surrounding game chips (stones, dots - it does not matter). And in this sense, shortcut a la Szkrab is a step towards game for territory, because it allows under certain conditions to get points for surrounded empty spaces.
|
Then your definition of 'territory rules' is different than ours, but I can agree with your point of view.
| Volunteer napisał: |
In the course of the discussion, I repeated many times the same thing: only scoring. If the number of points depends on the surrounding area (no matter how exactly it is counted), then this game is for territory. If the number of points depends only on the surrounded dots, then this is a game without territory. This is our position, with which you are not obligated to agree. As well as we are with yours. |
OK, but just note that according to your definition there are no territory rules on zagram or szkrab. What we have on zagram (and had on szkrab), is 'a step towards game for territory', as you wrote, but not real territory rules.
BTW, we had a discussion whether 'pass' should be allowed and whether we want real territory rules (in the sense of your definition, which now I understand as: pass is allowed, territory is scored after both players pass, like in Go), but there was a strong opposition against the real territory rules. |
|
| Powrót do góry |
|
|
Volunteer
Dołączył: 16 Lis 2017
Posty: 65
Skąd: Russia
|
| Wysłany: Sob Gru 16, 2017 4:18 pm Temat postu: |
|
|
| zagram_org napisał: | | What we have on zagram (and had on szkrab), is 'a step towards game for territory', as you wrote, but not real territory rules |
I agree, it turns out something intermediate.
| zagram_org napisał: | | we had a discussion whether 'pass' should be allowed and whether we want real territory rules |
We also discussed this issue. Especially those players who seriously played Go. But this is very few people supported, which is understandable. Why then it was necessary to remake Go in dots, if then again to return to the starting position? It's easier then to play Go and forget about dots.
P.S. Thank you all for your comments and interesting conversation. It was useful. I clarified for myself some details of the Polish rules and introduced into the article two edits (about kopper and about the "clear proof"). |
|
| Powrót do góry |
|
|
senny_mojrzesz
Dołączył: 04 Lis 2005
Posty: 1566
Skąd: Legionowo,Londyn
|
| Wysłany: Sob Gru 16, 2017 6:19 pm Temat postu: |
|
|
Thank You.
Possibly double English translation was not very helpful
I have a quastion about landing rules (different subject )
When you decide to start with cross in the middle,
are you happy with this solution? Or you still thinking about better solution to avoid many ties games if someone like to play passively, or both players don't want to risk |
|
| Powrót do góry |
|
|
Volunteer
Dołączył: 16 Lis 2017
Posty: 65
Skąd: Russia
|
| Wysłany: Pon Gru 18, 2017 10:23 pm Temat postu: |
|
|
| senny_mojrzesz napisał: | | are you happy with this solution? |
The single cross gained popularity at "Points XT" and became "official" since the first offline tournaments in Kiev, which Kolosov spent (mid 2000's). Double cross and four single crosses came into use when our players began to play massively on "Zagram". The experience of holding tournaments in the last two years shows that even a single cross is doing its job well. Draws are few and they happen, as a rule, only when both opponents initially agree to a draw. But, if this is so, then the game will in any case end in a draw, regardless of the rules by which it is played. If the strong player is aimed at winning, then it is very difficult to defend without losing a single dot. Therefore, in games with rivals who play only from defense, no one tries to surround everything: took one dot in the attack and himself went into the defense. And let the opponent try to win. Sometimes, when approximately equal opponents play, the party turns into a swing: then one attacks, then another, while the difference in the score is minimal. |
|
| Powrót do góry |
|
|
Volunteer
Dołączył: 16 Lis 2017
Posty: 65
Skąd: Russia
|
| Wysłany: Pią Sty 26, 2018 11:05 pm Temat postu: Sport Dots Ultimate Struggle Match 2017 |
|
|
January 8-9, 2018 in Moscow, the match for the title of the absolute champion of sport dots in 2017 took place. In this match met Sergei Chernobrovin aka Nnoitora and Igor Shlimak aka NIZBAGOYNIY MACTEP.
In order to participate in the match, the players went through a difficult selection. Throughout 2017 they played in official tournaments, getting a sports rating, which is calculated by the Sevastopol Sport Dots Club. In November, eight players with a maximum rating fought in the candidates tournament. The first two in this tournament got tickets to the match for the title.
The match consisted of six games. Sergei Chernobrovin won with a score of 4-2 and became the first ever absolute champion.
Photo report on the match can be viewed in our group on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=oa.657708214352802&type=3
A video report with English subtitles is on our Youtube channel: https://youtu.be/vEU6Q4rYrCM
Tournament web page: https://tensu.ru/events/sdusm17/
Ostatnio zmieniony przez Volunteer dnia Pon Kwi 12, 2021 1:54 pm, w całości zmieniany 7 razy |
|
| Powrót do góry |
|
|
Volunteer
Dołączył: 16 Lis 2017
Posty: 65
Skąd: Russia
|
| Wysłany: Pią Lut 09, 2018 7:57 pm Temat postu: Sport Dots League - Regular Championship 2018 |
|
|
On February 11, the Regular Championship of 2018 will start. This tournament occupies a central place among all competitions conducted according to Russian rules.
This tournament is official: players receive a sports rating (rating list of the Sevastopol Club), entrance fees are provided, a money prize fund is played out.
The championship consists of two stages: Spring and Autumn. Each stage is held in two circles. Participants are divided into two divisions according to the sports rating: the first (10 players) and the second (8 players). At the end of each stage, there will be rotation between the divisions. In addition, those who leave the second division can be replaced by winners of a special qualifying tournament.
As a result of the tournament, the title of regular champion will be drawn in 2018.
Tournament web page: https://tensu.ru/events/sdlrc18/
Ostatnio zmieniony przez Volunteer dnia Pon Kwi 12, 2021 2:13 pm, w całości zmieniany 4 razy |
|
| Powrót do góry |
|
|
Volunteer
Dołączył: 16 Lis 2017
Posty: 65
Skąd: Russia
|
| Wysłany: Sob Mar 31, 2018 1:16 pm Temat postu: Sport Dots League - Regular Championship 2018 |
|
|
April 1, 2018 will begin the second part of the spring stage of the regular championship. On this day, there will be one round in each of the two divisions (the beginning of the games at 20:00 Msk). As a result of the stage, players will be determined who will change the first division to the second and vice versa. Two outsiders of the second division will leave the championship, their place will be taken by the finalists of the recently passed qualifying tournament.
Ostatnio zmieniony przez Volunteer dnia Pon Sie 03, 2020 2:58 pm, w całości zmieniany 1 raz |
|
| Powrót do góry |
|
|
Volunteer
Dołączył: 16 Lis 2017
Posty: 65
Skąd: Russia
|
| Wysłany: Wto Maj 29, 2018 5:46 pm Temat postu: 2018 Blitz Championship |
|
|
On May 27, the 2018 Blitz Championship finished. Igor Shlimak aka NIZBAGOYNIY MACTEP won the gold medal and the title of the champion. Oksana Dymarchuk aka Ęńţőŕ198 became the silver medalist, Roman Saraskin aka Putin became the bronze medalist.
Tournament web page: https://tensu.ru/events/sdlbc18/
Ostatnio zmieniony przez Volunteer dnia Pon Kwi 12, 2021 1:55 pm, w całości zmieniany 3 razy |
|
| Powrót do góry |
|
|
Volunteer
Dołączył: 16 Lis 2017
Posty: 65
Skąd: Russia
|
| Wysłany: Czw Cze 21, 2018 2:10 pm Temat postu: Polish rules on "Sport Dots" |
|
|
The game application "Sport Dots" supports the game according to Polish rules. However, some time ago, errors and shortcomings were revealed, because of which it was almost impossible to play for the territory. A few days ago we downloaded an update in which these bugs were fixed. In particular:
1. Fixed a bug due to which the manual environment button sometimes did not become active.
2. The calculation of points for the early termination of the game is brought into compliance with the Polish rules.
3. Added a starting position with a clean field and the ability to put dots at any points with the first move.
The functionality of the manual environment and the way to complete the game by counting points is similar to what you are used to on "Zagram".
In addition, in this update was added another type of control of game time - Fisher's clock.
Updates need to be tested, so we will be grateful for your feedback.
Ostatnio zmieniony przez Volunteer dnia Pon Sty 25, 2021 12:36 pm, w całości zmieniany 1 raz |
|
| Powrót do góry |
|
|
Volunteer
Dołączył: 16 Lis 2017
Posty: 65
Skąd: Russia
|
| Wysłany: Pią Sie 10, 2018 1:27 pm Temat postu: Cup of Nations 2018 |
|
|
One of these days the selection tournament of the Russian national team has come to the end.
The right to play at the Nations Cup was given to Sergei Chernobrovin aka Nnoitora, Igor Shlimak aka NIZBAGOYNIY MACTEP, Roman Saraskin aka Putin, Sergei Nosanov and Vasily Sidorenko. Selection of the Ukrainian team is scheduled for September. The composition of the Belarusian team will be determined by the captain of the team. We remind you that the Nations Cup is scheduled for October this year.
Ostatnio zmieniony przez Volunteer dnia Pon Kwi 12, 2021 1:55 pm, w całości zmieniany 4 razy |
|
| Powrót do góry |
|
|
senny_mojrzesz
Dołączył: 04 Lis 2005
Posty: 1566
Skąd: Legionowo,Londyn
|
| Wysłany: Sob Sie 11, 2018 7:29 pm Temat postu: |
|
|
thx for info but looks like we have no team. have we?
czy ktoś nadal gra I chce wziąć udział?
Kubusio?
Bartek?
Mała Mi?
Paweł_?
Baobab?
Michał?
Kaczus?
ktoś z niewymienionych? |
|
| Powrót do góry |
|
|
|
|
Nie możesz pisać nowych tematów
Nie możesz odpowiadać w tematach
Nie możesz zmieniać swoich postów
Nie możesz usuwać swoich postów
Nie możesz głosować w ankietach
|
|
FAQ
Szukaj
Użytkownicy
Grupy
Rejestracja
Profil
Zaloguj się, by sprawdzić wiadomości
Zaloguj
